Ivo Giesen, ‘The Use and Influence of Comparative Law in “Wrongful Life” Cases’

How do judges decide cases in a globalised legal context, characterised by the increased interconnections between legal systems and between actors in these legal systems? In this article, firstly, four types of variables (constitutional, institutional, organisational, and personal) which influence judicial practices are described, and it is shown how these variables shape the judicial decision-making of the highest courts in liberal-democratic legal systems. Secondly, the specific development of the use of foreign law in the Supreme Courts of the UK and the Netherlands is analysed in light of the identified variables. In this way, some general insights are provided into the development of judicial decision-making under the effects of globalisation, and it is made clear what the national highest courts can and may do in the specific context in which they are functioning.

Ivo Giesen, The Use and Influence of Comparative Law in ‘Wrongful Life’ Cases. Utrecht Law Review, Volume 8, Issue 2, May 2012.

First posted 2012-05-22 13:46:34

Leave a Reply