Private Law Theory

ABSTRACT
A law of public office crystallized in Anglo-American law in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. This body of law – defined and enforced through a mix of oaths, statutes, criminal and civil case law, impeachments, and legislative investigations – imposed core duties on public officeholders: Officials needed to serve the public good, not their own private interests; were barred from acting ultra vires; could often be required to account to the public for their conduct in office; and needed to act with impartiality, honesty, and diligence. Office-holding came to be viewed as conditional, with officers removable for misdeeds. This law of public office reflected something that looks similar to modern fiduciary duties of loyalty and care.

In this Essay, we extend the historical record describing this law of public office, and make several new claims – historical and theoretical. First, there are strong reasons to suspect that the law of public office and private fiduciary duties developed together and influenced each other. During the critical centuries we explore, the duties of officeholders such as trustees, executors, and corporate directors were developing alongside the duties of officials such as tax collectors and government commissioners. Parliament and other actors repeatedly used the language of trust, trusteeship, guardianship, and account to define the law of public offices. And public law concerns about abuse of power and the need for honesty, fidelity, and altruism in service of others may have seeped from public law into private fiduciary law. Influential political theory about the monarchy and lesser magistrates was also using trust and related legal language to set forth a fiduciary conception of public office-holding; the theoretical developments in political theory not only drew from legal concepts but may have helped shape them, as well …

Leib, Ethan J and Kent, Andrew, Fiduciary Law and the Law of Public Office: Suggestions for a Research Agenda (July 17, 2020). William and Mary Law Review, forthcoming.

First posted 2020-07-23 04:59:23