ABSTRACT
This paper examines how Canadian defamation law seeks to reconcile two fundamental and sometimes competing values: freedom of expression and the protection of reputation, dignity, and privacy. It compares the treatment of civil defamation in Quebec’s civil-law system with the common-law approach in English Canada, while also considering the continuing role of criminal defamatory libel and the development of anti-SLAPP legislation.
The paper argues that, despite doctrinal differences, both legal traditions pursue a common objective of balancing expressive freedom against the protection of individual reputation. It examines the distinctive Quebec approach, in which even truthful statements may in some circumstances attract liability where their publication is unreasonable, and contrasts this with the common-law framework and its emphasis on defences such as justification, fair comment, privilege, and responsible communication.
The paper then considers how anti-SLAPP legislation and constitutional values have shifted the balance toward freedom of expression, while potentially creating barriers for individuals seeking to vindicate reputational harm. It argues that criminal defamation should be reconsidered because of its chilling effect, while civil remedies should better address serious reputational and privacy harms. Particular attention is given to the digital environment, where online publication can magnify the persistence, reach, and personal consequences of reputational harm. The paper concludes that Canadian defamation law should continue to evolve toward a more coherent balance between expression, dignity, privacy, and meaningful access to remedies.
Liu, Eileen Na, Defamation, Dignity and Freedom of Expression in Canada: A Comparative Analysis of Quebec Civil Law and the Common Law (January 31, 2023).
Leave a Reply