ABSTRACT
Without thorough consideration, and in reliance on a single federal district court case which made an Erie guess, the Mississippi Court of Appeals summarily adopted the preemption rule in 2017 and summarily affirmed it in 2024. Pursuant to the rule, employers who are sued for vicarious liability and direct negligence (negligent hiring, negligent training, negligent entrustment, and negligent failure to establish reasonable protocols) may move to dismiss the direct negligence claim on the pleadings before discovery if they admit that the employee whose conduct is at issue was acting in the scope of employment. Application of the rule often renders the employer’s practices beyond the scope of discovery, thereby shielding them from public scrutiny and decreasing tort law’s deterrent effect. In addition, the rule is completely inconsistent with comparative fault principles because exclusion of the direct negligence claim from the jury’s consideration will force the jury to allocate fault that would been allocated to the employer based upon the employer’s negligence to the plaintiff (if the plaintiff was also negligent), to the employee and to any other tortfeasors. This distorted allocation of fault directly contradicts MCA §85-5-7, which requires the factfinder to allocate fault to all persons whose fault caused the plaintiff’s injuries.
Given that adoption of the preemption rule has significant implications, it is not surprising that interested parties have contentiously debated its merits. Those in favor of the rule argue that it preserves resources, prevents the jury’s consideration of prejudicial evidence, and avoids excessive verdicts against employers. Those opposed to the rule argue that it conflicts with comparative fault principles, decreases deterrence and accountability, and is unnecessary given the wide array of existing procedural and evidentiary rules that were adopted to address the very concerns raised by proponents of the rule. This Article argues that the Mississippi Supreme Court should reject the preemption rule because it is inconsistent with MCA §85-5-7 and is contrary well-established principles of Mississippi jurisprudence and tort law’s goal of promoting safety and accountability.
Percy, Farish, ‘It’s Not My Fault’: Mississippi Employers Should Not Be Permitted To Avoid Direct Liability By Admitting Vicarious Liability In The Event Of Employee Negligence (August 15, 2025), forthcoming in Volume 95 of the Mississippi Law Journal (Spring 2026).
Leave a Reply